Thursday, 16 February 2012

Random Rant: Racism

SO the big thing recenty in the world of football (aside from Capello resigning) is racism, and two incidents in particular; Terry and Suarez.
I want to talk about Suarez, and specifically about Liverpool and their shambolic handling of the case.
The facts as I see them are as follows;
Suarez admitted to using a derogatory term to Evra at least once.
The FA ban Suarez.

This would seem quite logical. There was some discussion over how many times the word was used and the context of the word but basically an independent panel deemed that Suarez was guilty and banned him. The reaction since by Liverpool and their supporters has been laughable, or at least it would've been if it hadn't have been not in the least bit amusing. These are some of the arguments I've seen recently;

1. Evra is a liar or that he uses the race card.
This was tackled, disgracefully, in an actual statment by Liverpool. The fact is that this is the first time Evra has accused someone of racial abuse. Prior incidents where he has been involved it has been others who have made the accusations. When it comes to him being a liar, I don't see how that stands up at all, given that Suarez himself admitted using the word and the panel heard testimonies from several other players and staff from both clubs that proved Evras's testimony. The same statements (from Liverpool's own staff) that proved Suarez's testimony was unreliable.

2. The conspiracy theory; Evra not being charged in the same way, John Terry not being charged in the same way.
So the FA are out to get Liverpool and are basically all United fans. Right. It has been said that Evra should be charged too for his abuse of Suarez that aparently provoked him. As far as I know, no-one has raised a complant against Evra, so he has nothing to answer too. Him insulting Suarez might make him an unsavory character, butthat isn't the issue. It doesn't matter if Evra is a saint or an arsehole. Every players gets and gives abuse out on the football pitch, the issue here is Suarez *racially* abused Evra. Evra did not racially abuse Suarez. Terry's case is being handled diffeently because the police got involved following a complaint made to them by a member of the public. The FA can't intevene until that case is completed. When it is, they might well charge Terry in the same way that they did suarez.

3. On a related note; they took Evra's word over Suarez, there wasn't any real evidence.
The FA are not a court of law and they charge players based on probability. So if there is enough evidence to support what happened, they will find the player guilty. But it was not one player's word against the other. Liverpool's own lawyers signed off on the fact that it wasn't; they agreed that there was enough evidence to convict. Why do you think they didn't appeal? Evra's testimony was cross checked against many others and found to be corroborotive. Suarez's was not.

Regardless of the severity of the ban, after being found guilty, that should have been it. There might've been a bit of a sense of injustice, they might have hated Evra, but Liverpool should have accepted that their own player admitted to saying a word that he shouldn't have done, therefore he deserved his punishment.

Instead, no apology was forthcoming. The club supported Suarez and treated the whole thing like they had been hard done by. They supported a player who had been charged with racially abusing another player. They booed a player who had spoken up about being racially abused.

Then came the hadnshake. Just when you thought it couldn't get any worse, the chance to diffuse the situation and at least stop it from dragging on was rejected.
Eventually, after widespread condemnation, Liverpool and Suarez released PR apologies without meaning, but even then some fans tried to claim injustice and released pictures of the handshake trying to claim that Evra was the one who didn't shake hands.

I've been amazed by the lengths people will go to in supporting a player because he plays for their club, even though he is so blatantly in the wrong. It's depressing really and I do feel sorry for Liverpool in a funny way that they got this so badly wrong and have now tainted the club and it's history with the stench of racism.

Such a shame.

No comments:

Post a Comment